Bulletin
Investor Alert

MarketWatch First Take

April 13, 2011, 4:13 p.m. EDT

GE shareholders not laughing

Commentary: Prank knocks $3.5 billion off GE’s market cap

By MarketWatch

SAN FRANCISCO (MarketWatch) — As far as hoaxes go, it was hilarious. Unless you got caught on the wrong side of the trade.

/quotes/comstock/13*!ge GE 19.94, -0.07, -0.36%
Hoax's ax
20.20
20.10
20.00
19.90
19.80
8a
10a
12p
2p
4p
6p
GE shares intraday.

According to a bogus press release sent out early Wednesday, General Electric /quotes/comstock/13*!ge (GE 19.94, -0.07, -0.36%)  CEO Jeffrey Immelt was purported to have informed the White House the company would be “gifting” a $3.2 billion federal tax refund to Uncle Sam on April 18, Tax Day, in a bid to “secure its position as a leader in corporate social responsibility.” Read full story about the hoax.

The tiny guerrilla team calling itself Yes Men claimed responsibility for the hoax, their latest in a series of stunts aimed at companies that espouse corporate citizenship while bulking up their bottom lines via generous tax loopholes. The hit on GE was especially timely given the controversy over the company’s true tax status stirred up by a recent New York Times report.


Reuters
GE’s Jeffrey Immelt listens to a reporter's question after an April 4 meeting with Japan's trade minister in Tokyo.

According to the newspaper, GE received a $3.2 billion tax credit on its 2010 income despite posting a $5.1 billion profit from its U.S. operations. GE officials claim nothing could be farther from the truth, though they haven’t been much help explaining what the truth is.

Meanwhile, Immelt makes an especially ripe target for these guys given his new role as an economic adviser to President Barack Obama, who, by the way, has called for narrowing the loopholes the titans of U.S. commerce use to avoid paying taxes. See First Take commentary on Immelt’s joining Team Obama .

But the hoax, dolled up as a very authentic-looking GE press release, fooled at least one news organization and then daisy-chained through other media outlets before getting yanked. But by then the damage was done.

GE shares fell 1.6% from their preopen high. Not a huge move, but enough to briefly trim GE’s market capitalization by nearly $3.5 billion.

How much of that was caused by the Yes Men? On a morning when most other companies in the Dow Jones Industrial Average were pretty flat, it’s tempting to think that at least some of GE’s pullback was the result of the hoax. We may never know, but there probably are several lawyers already looking into it, either on behalf of the company or its shareholders.

The episode is also cause for concern over at the Securities and Exchange Commission. One of that agency’s many tasks is to make sure people don’t manipulate share prices, and that includes issuing false statements about publicly traded companies.

It’s far from clear whether the SEC has the bandwidth to mount an investigation. But if you were hoodwinked into selling GE stock this morning, you’d appreciate it if the regulators at least gave the Yes Men a severe tongue lashing.

Of course, that would probably have about as much impact as saying it’s time to close those tax loopholes.

Jim Jelter

/quotes/comstock/13*!ge General Electric Co (GE)
/marketstate/country/US The market is open7:53:00 pm The market is closed7:53:00 pm
$ 19.94
Change -0.07 -0.35%
Volume 40.05m Real time quotes

Explore related topics

Comments (55) Community Commons

BayviewMortgageInc 2 hours ago

+4 Votes
 
GEEEEEEEE

EddyCurrents 2 hours ago

+15 Votes
 
The right thing to do would have been to say, yeah, those guys were right, we should pay our fair share and America needs the money more than we do, instead of giving America the finger yet again.

eagle3 2 hours ago

+6 Votes
 
Eddy:

For GE to do that which you suggest, "America needs the money more than we do", would be a violation of law as well as a violation of their fiduciary responsibility. Their fiduciary responsibility is to maximize shareholder value. Corporations do not exist to assist the Government. Government can and does very well without assistance.

Metanoia 1 hour ago

+4 Votes
 
True, the purpose of corporations is to maximize profits and shareholder value. But it should also be done through ethical means.

It has always been the case that every financial crisis was caused by a few executives who have crossed the line due to conflicts of interests....and their efforts to justify their exorbitant pays & bonuses. And that is the fundamental problem.

Randy M 2 hours ago

+6 Votes
 
F-U Jeffrey, if you can't take a joke.

IBFRANK 2 hours ago

+6 Votes
 
Anyone in their right mind would know that GREED-E would never volunteer to pay their fair share of taxes!

eagle3 1 hour ago

+3 Votes
 
You and their responsibility is to minimize the amount of taxes you legally owe. Only a fool would knowing pay more than owed. If you want to make a gift, write a check payable to the IRS.

Kruzer 2 hours ago

+6 Votes
 
I own lots of GE stock and I would have been happy if the letter was true. It would have set an example for other multi nationals.

eagle3 1 hour ago

+2 Votes
 
Kruzer:

Gift your shares to the government if that is your true sentiment.

Tyranny 1 hour ago

+11 Votes
 
Absolutely friggin' hilarious! Plus it proved to the American public just how lazy our leftist, Obama-worshiping US media is. Usually the media tries to create or "guide" public opinion via carefully worded polls & surveys but this was SO MUCH funnier!

All you have to do is print up a fancy little public release on official looking letterhead, email and fax it around to the lazy leftist US media, and sit back and watch them chomp on it -- hook, line, & sinker. Apparently 21st century "reporters" think repeating whatever gets forwarded to them is a lot better than actually going out and doing real research, vetting sources, and otherwise performing true journalism for a living!

DayTrader67 1 hour ago

+1 Vote
 
Lol, when was CNBC a lefttist US media.
They cater to the rich aka "affluent" is the word they use to explain themselves now.

Manq2 24 minutes ago

0 Votes
 
According to Tyranny; Limbaugh is a leftist bleeding heart liberal.

seagull921 1 hour ago

0 Votes
 
If a corporation makes misleading statements it can be sued by shareholders. If you lie to a judge in court you can go to prison. There is a difference between freedom of press and doing something with malicious intent. Of course, everyone on the web is probably at fault for false claims, but this prank could have hurt regular investors. So, it falls under the law as something that can be prosecuted.

eagle3 1 hour ago

+2 Votes
 
seagull:

Only if they profited from the press release. That does not seem to be the case.

AmericanMade 1 hour ago

+1 Vote
 
There is a thing called class action law suit. The difficulty will be in proving the release effected the share price to the detriment of others.

WILLIAMG 1 hour ago

+6 Votes
 
That doe's it i'm taking my $14 dollars out of GE stock and moving it to an ethical company..Bank of America or AIG.

swschrad 1 hour ago

0 Votes
 
LOL, make sure they don't sell innocent little puppies to chemical laboratories for experiments if the owners bounce a check.

TrustandVerify 1 hour ago

0 Votes
 
Yes Men meet G-Men. Game over.

ChrisW 1 hour ago

+2 Votes
 
GE doesn't need to pay taxes since their CEO is a good buddy with Obama. Too many liberal politicians conveniently forget to pay taxes. Yet the liberal left wants to raise taxes on anyone who doesn't agree with their politics.

Keeg 1 hour ago

+2 Votes
 
Right, the SEC doing something? AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA - these fools did ZERO after the American Airline news article, could not find out - or will not tell - who shorted the airlines on 9/11. and could not even catch ole Bernie Madoff with the evidence staring them in the face.

Face it the SEC makes the members of the House and Senate look smart.

oldman2 1 hour ago

+1 Vote
 
Obama DOES NOT want to tax the rich...
He DOES want to tax PRODUCTIVITY

His taxes will target the the most productive who are creating Americas wealth...Not the old money sitting in trust funds.
Trust fund babies like Mark Dayton in MN or John Kerry in Mass. wont get their trust funds raided by the IRS.
These people has never worked a day in his life or used their money to create a single job.

Young successful start up " Rags to Rich's stories who create innovative products and create real jobs will the the ones he will penalize.

He wants to make sure if you are poor... have a great idea .. and want to work hard ..that you stay poor.

Manq2 33 minutes ago

0 Votes
 
No, he just wants to tax you, personally. It's a conspiracy I tell you!!!!! A conspiracyyyyyyy!!!!!!!!

lol

HERCULOS 59 minutes ago

+1 Vote
 
Bulls' push......to no avail............Sentiment still bearish!
Another step Today....................towards the ABYSS.
Another 30% Down and..........I'll be shopping..........AGAIN!
It just hit me!

sprink 12 minutes ago

0 Votes
 
During an interview with Kudlow, Mitt Romney was asked if he would support a flat tax with no loopholes. His responce was that he thought the bigger tax break should go to the middle class. In all honesty the middle class would pay about the same amount as they do now. Do the math at say a 12% rate on your total income, not your adjusted income and see how close it is. Now comes the problem and Mitt knows it. People earning millions will be paying a whole lot more at 12% of unadjusted income[which would be their fair share] than they do now with their legions of tax consultants and lawyers looking for every possible way to shelter their income. They will not stand for a flat tax because they can't game the system.

imagine1 1 minute ago

0 Votes
 
this disgrace of a company not paying its taxes by using loop holes in the system is what is not funny.no one has to buy a ge product so dont!

Add a Comment

Post to Facebook | Track Responses
Add Cancel

First Take

GE shareholders not laughing

A runaway prank briefly knocks $3.5 billion off GE’s market value.

4:13 p.m. Today

MarketWatch's Latest Tweets

"Eyes are on Wells Fargo in wake of J.P. Morgan http://bit.ly/dJSDlY"
5:32 p.m. EDT, April 13, 2011 from MarketWatch

"Barry Bonds guilty of obstructing justice, jury deadlocked on other charges: reports http://on.mktw.net/hUEm9m"
4:52 p.m. EDT, April 13, 2011 from MarketWatch

"#IPO pricings to highlight after-hours session http://bit.ly/gAOOa4"
4:31 p.m. EDT, April 13, 2011 from MarketWatch

"NYSE Euronext considers special dividend linked to Deutsche Boerse deal: report http://on.mktw.net/hMCa5Q"
3:20 p.m. EDT, April 13, 2011 from MarketWatch

"U.S. stocks finish with modest gains; Dow rises 7 points http://on.mktw.net/hCWzDi"
3:04 p.m. EDT, April 13, 2011 from MarketWatch

Featured Commentary »

ALERT:

Link to MarketWatch's Slice.

Email address or display name

Password

Forgot password?