Reuters Alertnet Foundation Logo
Alerting humanitarians to emergencies
 Username: 
 Password: 
 Sign me in automatically
About AlertNet  | Why join AlertNet?  | Help
You are here: Homepage > Newsdesk > Imposter hits chemical giant with Bhopal payout hoax

LOW GRAPHICS
GET WEEKLY EMAIL
ALERTNET QUIZ

Typhoons wreak havoc in the Philippines

Powered by SUN
Imposter hits chemical giant with Bhopal payout hoax
03 Dec 2004 22:05:49 GMT
Source: Reuters
(Adds identity of hoaxer)

By Jeffrey Goldfarb

LONDON, Dec 3 (Reuters) - The BBC's international TV news channel apologised after being duped into airing an interview with a fake Dow Chemical spokesman who said the firm would pay billions of dollars in compensation for India's Bhopal disaster.

BBC World broadcast the promise on Friday by a man identified as Jude Finisterra, but later said it had been the victim of "an elaborate deception".

Dow Chemical says it bears no responsibility for one of the world's worst industrial disasters, 20 years ago on Friday, in which more than 3,500 people died after lethal gas escaped from a chemical plant in the central Indian city Bhopal.

Activist Andy Bichlbaum convinced the British public broadcaster he was a Dow spokesman by putting his number on a fake Web site for the company. The BBC acknowledged it had been duped and apologised for airing the hoax.

Bichlbaum later said his goal was to show that "another world is possible" if Dow did the right thing and paid victims.

In the interview, he told the BBC Dow Chemical was taking responsibility for the disaster and would pay $12 billion to victims.

Dow Chemical quickly said the story was not true and "Finisterra" was not its employee. The company says it bears no legal responsibility for the disaster and owes victims nothing.

The Bhopal factory was owned by Union Carbide, now a Dow subsidiary, which paid $407 million to Bhopal residents in 1989.

Several other news organisations including Reuters reported the phoney spokesman's comments to the BBC. Reuters withdrew its story once BBC World said it had been deceived.

"We apologise to Dow and to anyone who watched the interview who may have been misled by it," the BBC said in a statement read out during a subsequent news bulletin. "Of course, the BBC is investigating how the deception happened."

TEARS OF JOY

Britain's Channel 4 television news later identified "Finisterra" as Bichlbaum, whose "Yes Men" group hoaxes businesses and governments and has targeted Dow before over Bhopal.

Bichlbaum told Channel 4 he had carried out the hoax to show what the company should do for the victims for the disaster.

"The 120,000 people that are estimated to need medical care because of the Bhopal catastrophe are going to need it for their whole lives. They've already needed it for 20 years," he said.

Bichlbaum said he heard Bhopal residents broke down in tears when hearing of the report and he felt bad they were disappointed.

"There were people in tears of joy when they found out, and indeed it is very sad that this isn't the case. But you have to realise that this is Dow's doing: Dow could make the tears of joy real," he said.

He could face civil and criminal legal action if tracked down, legal experts say. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has in the past filed charges against individuals who have issued fraudulent statements about firms.

"Finisterra has made false statements that have a connection with a trading market and if he knew they were false, that is a crime," said Professor Steve Thel of New York's Fordham Law School. The SEC declined to comment.

Dow <DOW.N><DOW.F> shares fell 0.6 percent to $49.64 in morning trading on the New York Stock Exchange, which took place after the hoax had been unmasked. They had earlier fallen in Frankfurt after the report by some two euros -- more than three percent -- but recovered to 37.40 euros, just 20 cents down. (Additional reporting by Peter Graff, Myra MacDonald and Andrew Cawthorne in London, Chris Sanders in New York, Karey Wutkowski in Washington and Timothy Heritage in Paris)

AlertNet news is provided by

Printable view  |  Email this article  |  Send comments

Typhoon Muifa


Small country map
© 2004 Europa Technologies Ltd.
India profile

· View Puri
· View Bhopal
· View Indi


Poor are Paying the Price of Rich Countries' Failure
Oxfam GB - UK

Nairobi Summit: a springboard for action toward a mine-free world
ICBL - USA

CrisisWatch N16, 1 December 2004
ICG - Belgium

HIV and AIDS: Give higher priority to preventative work for women and girls
Norwegian Church Aid - Norway

First Guide for Humanitarian Emergency Response to Extreme Man-made Disasters
Merlin - UK


Philippine rescuers see no new survivors from storm
Source: Reuters

Focus now on cleanup of Alaska wrecked cargo ship
Source: Reuters

'After Kyoto' takes center stage at climate talks
Source: Reuters

Floods in south Iran kill 10 people, injure 18-IRNA
Source: Reuters

Maoist rebels bomb Kathmandu for second day, 4 hurt
Source: Reuters


Disclaimers  |  Copyright  |  Privacy  |  Contact us  |  Feedback  |  About us
Sat Dec 11 14:54:35 2004