Loading...
The Choice iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
The Yes Men

GET UPDATES FROM The Yes Men
 

What Is a Gift?

Posted: 11/16/2012 5:46 pm

By K. Miles and Andy Bichlbaum

As the holiday season fast approaches, it has come to our attention that some of our city officials need some help understanding the concept of "gift."

On Monday, NYCHA chairman John Rhea visited a public housing complex that had been without power, water, or heat since Hurricane Sandy. He told the residents they would be required to pay full rent despite having no services, but that they'd get a rent credit in January, calling it "a nice little Christmas present."

It seems that Rhea needs a lesson in what constitutes a present and what doesn't.

First, what a gift isn't.

If you give someone something you stole from them, it's not a gift. If you give someone money you owe them, it's not a gift. If you wrongfully collect rent, knowing your tenants can legally refuse to pay because you're not providing basic services, and then you give part of that rent back two months later -- that's certainly not a gift.

Got it? Good. Now, what a gift actually is.

If a city's administration launches a coordinated attack on your movement, and then you come back to help save that city's ass when its underfunded agencies find themselves helpless in the face of disaster -- that's a gift. If a city's police force pepper-spray you, hit you with batons, and arrest you en masse for protesting Wall Street, and then, while that city (physically) bails out Wall Street, you pass out blankets to folks with no heat, develop a network of emergency shelters, and carry water up sixteen flights of stairs to public housing residents -- that's a gift. If a city violently evicts you from a park at which you provide free housing and medical care, and then you help provide it all over again when a storm renders thousands of new folks homeless -- that's a gift. A really, really nice one.

Last fall, the New York City mayor's office and police department tried to shut down the Occupy Wall Street movement by every means at their disposal. This fall -- working alongside many other grassroots groups, churches, and individuals to distribute donations and share resources with communities hit by the storm -- Occupy has ended up doing the city's job for them. While the city devoted huge efforts to making sure Wall Street could get back to work as quickly as possible, folks like these -- who have never been given "presents" from the city -- have stepped in to fill the void for everyone else.

For these people, such work is not a matter of gift-giving, but an act of common decency. They understand -- unlike John Rhea -- that food, medical attention, and livable housing are never "presents," but basic human rights.

Visit interoccupy.net/occupysandy/ to help New York residents still struggling after Hurricane Sandy. The Yes Men's new movie and platform explore how to take our democracy back.

Been to Occupy Wall Street?
If you've been to an Occupy Wall Street event anywhere in the country, we'd like to hear from you. Send OfftheBus your photos, links to videos or first-hand accounts of what you've seen for possible inclusion in The Huffington Posts's coverage.
 

Follow The Yes Men on Twitter: www.twitter.com/theyesmen

FOLLOW POLITICS

0
0
0 of your friends Commented on this article

By K. Miles and Andy Bichlbaum As the holiday season fast approaches, it has come to our attention that some of our city officials need some help understanding the concept of "gift." On Monday, NYCH...
By K. Miles and Andy Bichlbaum As the holiday season fast approaches, it has come to our attention that some of our city officials need some help understanding the concept of "gift." On Monday, NYCH...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 84
  • Pending Comments
  • 1
  • View FAQ
Edit your micro-bio.
photo
The Yes Men
Using humor and action to help take democracy back
Our moderators screen these comments before they are published
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
03:41 PM on 11/18/2012
The city showed it's priorities. Money and business bring income, not residents or services. The amount of rent paid is minimal ($10?). I am surprised that the author of this article does a bad job of journalism and does not cite a legal source for his opinion, which should not be in this article. The residents not paying their rent goes directly to our Federal Debt. It would take 2 months to reprogram the NYC housing software to either credit their rent or create this credit in January.
Flag as Abusive
11:03 PM on 11/18/2012
i'm not surprised.
you have done a poor job as well.
"amount of rent paid is minimal ($10?)"
not everyones life is the same as the life you have.

John Rhea should be fired ...
Flag as Abusive
02:33 PM on 11/18/2012
By the city ignoring these people and hoping they'll disperse into the general population (read as spread out and become homeless all over the place) then the city can let their developer friends and personal investments take over an area they've been eying for a LONG time... Wall Street had their power back immediately... it's always about the controlling interest and never about humanity when it comes to Bloomberg.
Flag as Abusive
11:05 PM on 11/18/2012
Bloomberg knows who his masters are ...
Flag as Abusive
02:00 PM on 11/18/2012
....in Ohio and Florida, being allowed to vote after waiting in line for several hours is clearly a gift from the incumbent President.....
Flag as Abusive
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Eyecre8
Open minds question even themselves
01:46 PM on 11/18/2012
This John Rhea person should be taken to court for breach of contract to the residents of that housing complex. What a disgusting, bureaucratic bully he is showing himself to be. No rent should be owed for a living facility that is not within city code, no excuses. Own up and be a man, instead of a caricatured representation of a Dickens villain straight from the workhouses of the 19th century. Does this man have a boss, does he answer to anyone, is the Mayor paying attention to his constituents, does no one have the wherewithal to set this person straight?. Have some common decency and a touch of human compassion. Despicable.
Flag as Abusive
03:43 PM on 11/18/2012
Eye - Rather than castigating John Rhea, what you should be doing is approaching the bondholders or the banks or the public employees retirement funds, or whoever loaned the money to build the housing complex, and ask them if it would be OK if the housing authority or whoever sponsored the complex might skip a monthly payment or two, seeing as how the power is out at the complex. You might get a different take on that "common decency" or that "human compassion" thing. I hope that is where your 401-k is invested.
Flag as Abusive
11:15 AM on 11/18/2012
What is a Gift..?.. Let's start with Tax Breaks for the Richest 1%....
Flag as Abusive
01:59 PM on 11/18/2012
or when the son of a prominent national politician seeks and obtains from the Selective Service four draft deferments to go to Harvard and then go proselytize, in France, for the next three years.
Flag as Abusive
photo
janmB
independent-mind-is-best
11:12 AM on 11/18/2012
There is an ongoing argument as to what we can expect in the USA as basic-human rights. This is a bountiful country and if a person is a citizen that gives them a right to share in basic rights. My opinion it's Food, shelter and healthcare.
Flag as Abusive
03:46 PM on 11/18/2012
And do you still have those rights if you don't contribute anything? If so, that means those who have to provide your food, shelter and health care are your slaves, right? I thought we did away with slavery?
Flag as Abusive
photo
janmB
independent-mind-is-best
05:28 PM on 11/18/2012
Yes you still have those rights if YOU haven't contributed anything because the majority are compassionate Americans. e More than a million youth betwn the ages of 13 and 29 receive some form of Social Security cash benefit support each month. Additionally the Social Security Administration reports that many young people with disabilities who enter their rolls are likely to remain on the programs for the rest of their lives.
This is only ONE example of our compassionate CHRISTIAN NATURE.
Flag as Abusive
11:11 PM on 11/18/2012
have you ever been to a nursing home?

do you have any relatives in one?
Flag as Abusive
10:47 AM on 11/18/2012
If the poor had any value in our "Christian society" there would be a market for them on Wall Street.
Flag as Abusive
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LindaWarnke
I think about stuff, so you don't have to
08:27 AM on 11/18/2012
Anyone who pays their rent in those damaged apartments needs their head examined.

First off, there isn't a judge or jury anywhere that would find in favor of Rhea's position, and the law provides for withholding rent when conditions are unlivable. So it would be beyond fascinating to see how Rhea would go about enforcing the rent collection. What's he going to do? Sue them? THAT would look real good on the evening news...Evict them? I can see it now...I imagine it would generate something of a media feeding frenzy...
People shouldn't fire their mouths off without thinking.
Flag as Abusive
03:48 PM on 11/18/2012
How about he just refuses to rebuild or re-connect the lights? Then the tenants would simply evict themselves.
Flag as Abusive
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LindaWarnke
I think about stuff, so you don't have to
06:01 AM on 11/19/2012
Is that like self-deportation?
Flag as Abusive
08:24 AM on 11/18/2012
public housing is made with a grant ....free tax payers money not to be paid back.....at no cost....but they get rent and steel from the poor after the tax payers paid for it....fun steel from the poor.....what elce is new......
Flag as Abusive
03:50 PM on 11/18/2012
Perhaps they could use the "steel" they get from the poor to build new cars.
Flag as Abusive
06:25 PM on 11/19/2012
what s the hold up....bandets or is it office holders????
Flag as Abusive
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
themightyabealrd
screw the real world-I'm an artist!
10:45 PM on 11/17/2012
A perfect example of a public official who has mastered the art of the condescending phrase. One wishes Rhea would be forced to go without utilities for weeks on end & be made to endure a similar statement from the energy companies responsible.
Flag as Abusive
02:41 PM on 11/17/2012
I think that New Jersey and New York should maybe offer their residents 6 months of free gas and electric. I really don't think it would even make a dent in their respective budgets and would be the right thing to do.
Flag as Abusive
11:02 PM on 11/18/2012
A lovely thought, but the states have no control over public utilities such as electric and gas.
Flag as Abusive
12:14 PM on 11/19/2012
It is different here, for something like that, we would get a rebate, that would help pay for the elecrtricity and gas.
Flag as Abusive
07:00 AM on 11/19/2012
There ain't no such thing as free gas and electric, nor a "free" lunch, either.
Flag as Abusive
12:11 PM on 11/19/2012
That is too bad, cause we have that here, something like that and we would get rebates to pay for electricity lost.
Flag as Abusive
11:42 AM on 11/17/2012
Hear that Romney. That 70 year old guy on social security and medicare that started working when he was 15 is not getting a gift from Obama.
Flag as Abusive
photo
unitron
Reverse Chron Order never stays checked
05:55 AM on 11/17/2012
A Christmas present that doesn't show up until after the first of the year?

That's a rather flexible use of the language, don't you think?
Flag as Abusive
01:10 PM on 11/17/2012
Flexible indeed.
Flag as Abusive
04:45 PM on 11/17/2012
Its commonly known as a Indian Giver , you give it then you take it back , just this time they take it first
Flag as Abusive
photo
unitron
Reverse Chron Order never stays checked
06:33 PM on 11/17/2012
Funny how the Indians (i.e., Native Americans) got blamed, not for what they did, but for what was done to them over and over again.

Must be where the GOP learned all that projection they do.
Flag as Abusive
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Daniel Kauwe
i like stuff except when i do not
01:34 AM on 11/17/2012
the never ending language wars...it's amusing how people will use a word for a purpose that it was not intended...

sometimes makes me think if humans really are innately programmed for language.
Flag as Abusive
01:06 AM on 11/17/2012
Seeing that the rent in public housing is 12 bucks a month and utilities are free, maybe a non-profit should come in and earn their tax-free status.
Flag as Abusive
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
callinguonit
Unpack your boxes Ann....
07:54 AM on 11/17/2012
YOU:12 bucks a month and utilities are free,
ME:  Where did you get that figure?  This is the true rate  for 1 BR  Tenant pay no electricity $ 941  Rent at Tenant pays Gas and Electricity $883... A percent of this from 40-60% is paid by subsidy... so At the bare minimum the amount paid by a tenant will be $353   http://www.nyc.gov/html/hpd/html/developers/low_income.shtml
Department of Housing and Development......NYC.gov
Flag as Abusive
07:05 AM on 11/19/2012
(Fair Market Value of apartment in New York) minus $363.00 = Gift-

Get it now?
Flag as Abusive
08:54 AM on 11/17/2012
You're full of it.
Flag as Abusive
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
OutToLunch
all hail the French & the Saunders...
11:36 AM on 11/17/2012
he clearly pulled that number right out his azzzz since it bears NO relation to reality.
Flag as Abusive